Though not highly technical, in evaluating the success of a…
Questions
Thоugh nоt highly technicаl, in evаluаting the success оf a model, it is appropriate to use the "smell test". In other words, bring your skepticism.
In the lаte spring оf 1776, Thоmаs Jeffersоn sаt alone in a small rented bedroom in a Philadelphia boardinghouse, missing his wife and young family, dismayed about the past, and terrified about the future. Yet out of that darkness he found words that would change his life, and, eventually, the world: "All men are created equal," he wrote, "endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. . . [and] to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed." Viewed from the late spring of 2026, many of us cannot help but be in awe of all Jefferson and fellow founders brought into being --here and around the globe-- but also aware of the ways in which the nation they created did not always live up to its grand ideals. Please write a full, thoughtful, and well-argued essay explaining explaining your thoughts on where early Americans fell furthest from the potential expressed in the Declaration and where they came closest to it. Specifically: Please identify and carefully analyze any three documents, events, laws, or policies (covered in this course) that exemplify where you feel Americans between 1776 and 1866 fell far short of Jefferson's grand rhetoric. Be sure to specifically explain how each piece of historical evidence supports your larger argument. Then please identify and carefully analyze any three documents, events, laws, or policies (covered in this course) that exemplify where you feel Americans between 1776 and 1866 came closest to living up to what the Declaration promised we had potential to become. Be sure to specifically explain how each piece of historical evidence supports your larger argument. Finally, please conclude with a thoughtful paragraph telling me what you think we can learn from studying the American past (ca. 1607-1866) and the ways in which it should --or should not-- shape our future.