Drawing on Nagel’s discussion of free will, reflect on wheth…

Questions

Drаwing оn Nаgel’s discussiоn оf free will, reflect on whether you think humаns truly have free will. According to Nagel, why does determinism pose a threat to free will, and what problems arise when we try to defend freedom by appealing to randomness or indeterminacy? Do you think Nagel believes free will can be fully explained, or does he see the problem as deeply puzzling and possibly unresolved? In your reflection, analyze a concrete example of choice—such as making a moral decision, resisting temptation, or choosing a career path—and explain how Nagel’s arguments cast doubt on or support the idea that the choice was made freely. Finally, assess whether you think moral responsibility requires free will in Nagel’s sense, or whether responsibility can survive even if our actions are determined.