Consider the following argument and its map. “What’s your o…

Consider the following argument and its map. “What’s your opinion of science? Do you, like those people mentioned above, place a high value on scientific research? Despite the unquestionable appeal of science, a bit of reflection shows that 1 we should terminate all scientific research. After all, 2 terminating all scientific research would make the world a safer place because 3 terminating all scientific research would prevent the development of new weapons and because 4 if we prevent the development of new weapons then the world will be safer. Obviously, 5 we have an obligation to create a safer world for our descendants, so 6 we should do whatever it takes to make the world a safer place.” MC 3.4a Central Argument.pngSuppose Allen thinks that premises 3, 4 and 5 are all good and that inferences A, B, and C are all very strong. Should he conclude that the argument, as a whole, is good?