The Kakapo is a large, flightless, nocturnal parrot native t…

The Kakapo is a large, flightless, nocturnal parrot native to New Zealand with fewer than 250 individuals remaining. Each bird costs approximately $80,000 per year to protect through intensive management (predator control, supplemental feeding, veterinary care, genetic management). Critics argue this money could save dozens of less charismatic species with higher recovery probabilities. Based on our author’s discussion of priority rankings, which consideration most strongly supports continuing Kakapo protection despite the high costs? Kakapo.png

Our author presents both the “cure-for-cancer” argument (som…

Our author presents both the “cure-for-cancer” argument (some species might someday be useful) and the argument that biodiversity has inherent value regardless of usefulness to humans. A student argues: “These two arguments contradict each other. If we claim species have value for their own sakes, we can’t also argue we should save them because they might benefit humans someday. That’s still treating them as resources.”Which of these best captures how our author would probably respond to this student’s argument?